Tiramisu Gelato

Temptress (Tiramisu Gelato Creami with Rum)

Share This Recipe

Temptress (Tiramisu Gelato Creami with Rum)

What could be more tempting than Tiramisu Gelato with Rum?   Cheesy Mascarpone goodness, Espresso, Chocolate, Spiced Rum and Lady Finger cookies.

If you feel sexy after enjoying tiramisu, there could be a good reason.  Tiramisu was invented by brothels in the northern Italian town of Treviso, renowned for its relaxed, ‘pleasure-focused’ people who love Tiramisu.

In Italian, tiramisu literally means “pull me up, or, more literally, “pull it up”.  Laced with sugar and alcohol, tiramisu is an energy bomb that not only tempts the taste buds, and lifts the spirit – but can also apparently provide a certain physical excitement- a “19th Century Viagra”

Tiramisu was developed as an aphrodisiac to reinvigorate exhausted clients inside the houses of ill-repute, before, during and after sex sessions to keep customers going and money flowing.

Tiramisu was a standard component of the business.  The more tiramisu swallowed, the more successful the prostitution business became.  Though the brothels of Treviso were outlawed in the 1960’s,  delicious Tiramisu is an enduring legacy.


Why will I love this Tiramisu Gelato with Spiced Rum?

  • If you love the Italian dessert, Tiramisu, you will LOVE this- this Gelato is the ultimate decadent gelato
  • Mascarpone cheese, Chocolate, Espresso- What a proven combination
  • Classic Tiramisu Ice Cream – Perfect for special indulgent moments!
  • Homemade Tiramisu with Spiced Rum goodness  -any time of year- right out of your freezer



Ingredients for our Traditional Tiramisu Gelato Ice cream Recipe:

Gelato / Ice Cream Base

  • Whole Milk
  • Heavy Cream
  • Mascarpone Cheese
  • Egg Yolks
  • White Sugar

Tiramisu Ingredients

  • Instant Espresso Powder
  • Spiced Rum
  • Cocoa Powder


  • Ninja Creami Ice Cream maker
  • Ninja Creami Ice cream pints
  • Medium Sauce pan
  • Whisk


Homemade Tiramisu Gelato with Rum

Tiramisu Gelato Recipe

Tiramisu Gelato
5 from 86 votes

Temptress (Homemade Tiramisu Gelato Creami

Tiramisu Gelato
Prep Time15 minutes
Active Time5 minutes
Total Time1 day
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: Italian
Keyword: Boozy Tiramisu Creami, Creami Tiramisu Gelato, Gelato Tiramisu, Ninja Creami Tiramisu, Temptress, Tiramisu Creami, Tiramisu Gelato, Tiramisu Gelato Creami
Yield: 8
Calories: 370kcal


  • 1 cup Whole Milk
  • 1 cup Heavy Cream
  • 1 cup Mascarpone Cheese
  • 5 Egg Yolks
  • ¾ cup Sugar
  • 1⅓ Tbsp Instant Espresso Powder
  • Tbsp Spiced Rum
  • 1 tsp Cocoa Powder


Heat the Milks

  • Heat the Whole milk, Heavy Cream, and Mascarpone on low heat. Stir Add the Espresso powder, and continue stirring until the mixture just starts to bubble on the edges. DO NOT BOIL Remove from heat (If you have a thermometer, you want the temperature to reach approximately 180 degrees F).

Prepare the egg mixture

  • In a separate bowl combine your egg yolks and sugar

Final Mix

  • Return the milk mixture to low heat, and stir in the egg yolk/sugar mixture. Again DO NOT BOIL. Keep stirring until fully blended, and then remove from heat
  • Let the Gelato cool for 5 minutes
  • Add the spiced Rum, and Cocoa. Stir until blended
  • Pour the Gelato liquid into 2 Ninja Creami pints. Freeze for at least 24 hours.

Ninja Creami Magic

  • Remove a pint of Gelato from the freezer, and remove the lid
  • Place the pint in the Ninja outer bowl with the paddle lid
  • Turn the Ninja Creami on, and place the bowl in the locked-in upright position. Push the Gelato button
  • Wait for the machine to turn off
  • Remove the bowl and serve immediately


Calories: 370kcal | Carbohydrates: 23g | Protein: 6g | Fat: 27g | Saturated Fat: 16g | Polyunsaturated Fat: 1g | Monounsaturated Fat: 4g | Cholesterol: 187mg | Sodium: 41mg | Potassium: 133mg | Fiber: 0.05g | Sugar: 21g | Vitamin A: 1043IU | Vitamin C: 0.2mg | Calcium: 113mg | Iron: 0.4mg

Canvas wine bag that says "Pairs well with Sassy Bitches"

Find fun Merch at Cuss Kitchen®



Ninja Creami Ice Cream FAQ’s

What the FAQ?


What is a Ninja Creami?  

The Ninja Creami transforms frozen solid bases into decadent frozen desserts, at the touch of a button.  From healthy to decadent, the Creami can create frozen treats that are delicious and healthful.  The Creami has pre-programmed settings for ice cream, sorbet, gelato, frozen yogurt, milkshake, smoothie bowl, slushy, Italian ice, frozen drinks, and ‘Creamiccino’.  The Creami works differently from a conventional maker, but quickly spins a frozen pint of ingredients into a mostly smooth ice cream, even with tricky, low-fat bases.



Why would I want to make Creami Ice Cream or Sorbet?

The Ninja Creami is fast and fun.  Get creative with textures, and flavors,  Make decadent flavor combinations, low-calorie, high protein desserts, or treats to accommodate special diets- Keto, Low-sugar, Lactose-free, or Vegan.

With the Creami, you simply pour your liquid base and ingredients in the Creami pint, and freeze it for 24 hours.  Once your mixture is frozen, you pop the lid off of the containers and drop them into the Ninja Creami.

Whether you’re a seasoned frozen dessert connoisseur or a rookie confection maker, this magical machine can revolutionize your dessert experience.




Why will I love Ninja Creami  Ice cream and Sorbet recipes?

  • Fast.  Create your culinary canvas in minutes- and freeze.  24 hours later the Ninja Creami grinds and smooths your ingredients into a specialty confection.
  • Fun.  There are so many options to create a dessert that is perfect for you and your family and friends
  • Variety. The Ninja Creami offers a wide range of dessert options, allowing you to experiment and create various frozen desserts like ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and more, specific to your taste and preferences.   Great for the perfect summer treat, but a delicious classic all year long.
  • Minimal ingredients. Most recipes require just a handful of ingredients, (with many you will have on hand)
  • Diet friendly. You can use this ice cream machine to make Keto, Lactose-free, low-calorie, protein, and even vegan ice creams.  Pure joy
  • Small servings. Each batch of ice cream makes just one pint, making it so fun to experiment with your favorite flavors- and varieties of frozen desserts- and just enough to share.
  • Customizable settings. Each button on the machine is specific depending on what you’d like to make- lite ice cream, smoothie bowls, or another other sweet treat.



What is the Ninja Creami process?

  1.  Add fresh ingredients to the Ninja Creami pint- Typically a base, fruit or savory flavor, other add-ins
  2. Freeze Ninja Pints and their contents
  3. Turn the Ninja Creami machine on.  Place the Ninja pint into the Ninja Creami’s machine outer bowl with the paddle lid, and position in the machine.  Press the appropriate button, and wait for your machine to do its magic.



What are typical bases for Ninja Creami ice cream?

Typical Creami Ice creams may use egg yolks, cream and sugar.   Other variations use a variety of milks, heavy whipping cream, and occasionally cream cheese, and even goat cheese.

For low-calorie ice creams, almond milk, cashew milk, or low-fat yogurt is often used in conjunction with sugar-free pudding powder.  Low calorie sweeteners include Stevia, Monk fruit, Swerve, Allulose.  Guar gum is sometimes used as a thickener, or way to avoid heavy creams.

Vegan Creami ice cream often feature non-dairy milks like almond or cashew.  They may also use Tofu, Cashew or Coconut butters, soaked nuts, even sweet potatoes and/or dates

Lactose-free milks or protein shakes are often used in Creami desserts for those with milk allergies

Some Creami desserts start with a Protein shake – Fairlife, B-Fit and Core Power shakes are popular options.


I have a pretty big ass. so even when I'm half-assing, the results are impressive



What are typical bases for Ninja Creami Sorbet?

Sorbet is typically simple syrup and pureed fruit.  Sorbets can include herbs, and alcohol



Can you use frozen fruit in a Ninja Creami?

If using frozen fruit, Dice or mince in a food processor.   Hard frozen fruit can damage your Ninja machine.  Fresh fruit can to add too much liquid to your recipe.



Can I add Fudge or Caramel to my Ninja Creami ice cream?

Fudge and Caramel, Nut butters, and Hazelnut spread do not mix well in the Ninja Creami.  These should be added after the dessert is blended.



How does the Ninja Creami work?

The Ninja Creami uses a different method of preparing cool and creamy treats.  The Creami uses technology that was previously only available in an expensive machine called the Pacojet.  The Creami  has an attached blade, which spins as it slowly moves into the frozen block of liquid.  The blade drills into the ice, shaving off pieces and whipping them together until the mixture forms a creamy dessert.





Why is my Creami ice cream crumbly?

Ice cream becomes crumbly for a variety of reasons, including not enough fat content, too much water content, or improper freezing.  Add 1/8 cup of milk, cream, or almond milk to your pint, and put the pint back into your Ninja on the re-spin cycle.  This re-spin cycle can be great friend to you!
The more time your ice cream is in the freezer- the more you will want to freshen it up, and add a small quantity of Almond milk- and re-spin.

Gelato Creami Tips

  • Do not fill the pints past the fill line- you could damage your machine
  • Always freeze Ninja pints level
  • Taste the Gelato mix before freezing to be sure you have the flavor/ sweetness you are looking for
  • Make sure you freeze your ingredients for at least 24 hours
  • If your gelato is a little crumbly, add a slight amount of milk and re-spin
  • Re-spin your Tiramisu Ice Cream with a little milk if you have been storing in the freezer for a while
  • Garnish with Ladyfingers cookies


Deliciously Rude logo


Cussing Creami’s

The most interesting ice cream and sorbet recipes for the Ninja Creami

Check out the best Ninja Creami recipes at Cuss Kitchen®

GTFO (Chocolate and Tahini Creami) How can Chocolate Tahini Creami Ice cream taste this good?  AND be healthy?  When you mix Chocolate, Tahini, and Dates,  you get one thing- the Ultimate Chocolate Decadence with a lush nutty flavor cream.  This Chocolate Tahini Creami comes together to create a rich and velvety dessert ice cream that is completely decadent- YET guilt-free, Lactose-free, Vegan, Low Calorie, and High Protein.  GTFO!



Drop it like its HOT  (Peach and Hot Honey Creami)    Enjoy Peach and Hot Honey Creami…  Cheesy, Creamy, Sweet with a sassy tang…Something different and delicious with simple healthy ingredients.  An amazing blend of cheesecake, Peach, Hot honey and banana.

No guilt in this scoop!  This luscious dessert has all the taste and lots of protein – only 105 calories per scoop.  Indulge yourself with a healthy, low calorie treat in no time- a velvety whipped dessert with simple healthful ingredients.



TDTM  (Pistachio Chocolate Creami)  Real Pistachio Chocolate Creami ice cream… OOOh Baby – Talk Dirty To Me!  What could be sexier than homemade Pistachio Ice cream with chunks of chocolate and toasted Pistachio?  A homemade creamy and flavorful base with chocolate and salty nuts. Healthy -Full of protein and under 130 calories per scoop.  You will love this homemade ice cream recipe.



‘Il Dolce far Niente’  (Aperol Spritz Sorbet Creami)  The classic cocktail for taking in the moment is surely the Aperol Spritz.  The drink was invented to combat the heat and humidity of the Italian Summer- refresh you from your day, and ready your appetite for the evening.   Why not take something classic and delicious,  and make it into a sorbet?  Light, Bright and boozy- What could be better?  Made with Blood Orange and Lemon juice, Aperol and Prosecco your taste buds will be singing.  Mama Mia!




Share This Recipe

4 Responses

5 from 86 votes (86 ratings without comment)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Skip to content